“I’m afraid so. Exceptions soon destroy the rule.” He looked over at
Puller. “But I can tell you some of my conclusions without revealing anything that I discussed with her.”
Puller sat up straighter. “Any information is more than we have now.”
Rooney took a drink of his lemonade and leaned back in his chair. “Your mother, I believe, understood your father better than any person on earth. She understood the almost ferocious ambition that he displayed over the years.”
“Based on what?” asked Puller.
Rooney settled his gaze on him. “Without getting into specifics, she often referred to the Puller family history. A generation removed from your father’s,” he added and then looked expectantly at Puller.
Puller thought about this for a few moments. “My paternal grandfather was a West Point grad too. He was in World War II.”
“And what was the highest rank he achieved?” asked Rooney.
“Captain.”
“And the reason for that?”
“He died on D-Day on the beaches at Normandy leading his platoon against the German fortifications. He was highly decorated and would have moved up in rank except for his death. He was considered for the Medal of Honor but didn’t get it. Paperwork got lost, so I heard.”
“And your father was how old when his father died?”
Puller quickly did the math in his head. “Eight.”
Knox said, “So are you saying Puller Sr. felt abandoned by his dad and worked his whole life to achieve more than his father had?”
“No,” said Rooney.
After a few moments of silence Puller said, “You think he was achieving all of it for his father? Because he never got the chance to do it himself?”
Rooney pointed at him. “That’s what I believe.”
“And did my mother think this too?”
“I can tell you that she had given it a lot of thought and more or less came to the same conclusion.”
“I found a letter from my mother to my father. She wrote it shortly before she disappeared. She said she wanted to make things work out. Mostly for the sake of my brother and me. But that she wanted to take me and my brother away from him for a bit so my father could better understand his priorities. Meaning his family over the Army, I guess.”
Rooney nodded. “That sounds like a decision Jackie would come to. She adored both you and your brother. And she loved your father. I’m breaking no vow to tell you that. But I could understand why she would want matters to come to a head. Taking his sons away from their father was a way for her to do that. She would force him to decide.”
Puller sat there mulling all of this over. “Is there anything you can tell me that might help me to find the truth, Father Rooney?”
The old man sat there for such a long time that Puller thought he might have fallen asleep.
Finally, Rooney stirred. “Your father came to see me several days after your mother went missing.”
Puller went rigid. “What did he want?”
“He wanted to take confession. And before you ask, I can say nothing about what he talked about.”
Puller looked frustrated. “Well, I’m not sure that’s very helpful, actually.”
“What I can tell you is that your father was devastated by her disappearance. I have never seen him so inconsolable. So if you’re thinking he had anything whatsoever to do with whatever did happen to her, well, I would say that you’re barking up the wrong tree. I’m afraid that’s all I can tell you, but I hope it helped. I have witnessed much guilt in the confessional, Agent Puller. And the only guilt your father had that day was not being there for the woman he loved when she needed him.”
Puller stood and held out his hand, which Rooney took.
“Thank you, Father. That was the most helpful thing I’ve heard in a very long time.”
Behind the glasses, the old priest’s eyes twinkled. “If you start going to Mass regularly you’ll hear something uplifting like that every Sunday.”
Finally, the thirty minutes were up and Rogers rose and unhooked the red rope.
“Single file, IDs ready. No problems, no trouble,” he called out in a loud voice. “Any fake IDs are subject to confiscation at my sole discretion. If you don’t like that rule, head somewhere else.”
The line of people surged forward.
Rogers had been given a special light like the TSA used at airports. If the person looked anywhere close to the age limit, and most did, he pulled it out and hit the surface of the ID. Three times he held on to the ID because it was fake but good enough to fool almost anyone without the same equipment. The two girls and one guy affected by this did not want to go quietly, but Rogers gave them a look that made them turn and leave.
Then came a group of guys big enough to look like they played major-college football. Three blacks and three whites, and none looked over twenty.